Categories

Blog powered by Typepad

« Garden Bloggers Bloom Day: 01.15.09 | Main | Wyeth on winter »

Friday, January 16, 2009

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Sarah Osborne

I was hoping someone else might post a comment so I could say something other than, "I love that song, I love those roses, I love David Thompson!" So here goes:

The song gives me chills, but as a historian, I take issue with the "wild and savage land" approach (and with anything that Harper endorses, ugh). Gordon Lightfoot uses a similar theme in the Canadian Railway Trilogy, and it drives me nuts! It's this backwards-looking excuse for nationalism and it whitewashes our history of colonization.

I also don't understand why nurseries grow hardy roses grafted onto rootstock? We bought a Henry Hudson rose a number of years ago, not on its own rootstock (apparent later). It made it through 1 or 2 winters before dying (and I live in NS, so we aren't talking prairie winter), and I have attempted for the last decade to convince my mother to let go of the pest-ridden twigs that have grew up from the root. She's an eternal optimist, a laissez-faire gardener, and frugal to boot, though, so it's a losing battle.

LINDA FROM EACH LITTLE WORLD

Sarah — Thanks so much for those thoughtful comments. I think the same thing is true in the U.S. — lots of songs are are only enjoyable until the moment when you really listen to the lyrics and the underlying message.

I only grow one rose (Alba plena) but would no longer consider growing anything but "own root." There are enough problems growing roses that you don't want to have to worry that the dieback will mean that you're suddenly growing the rootstock rose. I love the old roses and David Austin roses but I don't have the sun and it can get cold enough here that I just enjoy them when I see them elsewhere and let it go at that.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Contact

Words & Images

  • The copyright to photos on this Web site is held by the photographer, Mark Golbach, unless credited otherwise. Original text is copyright by Linda Brazill. Please contact for permission to use.